Social Media, What it Ain't
Did you hear about the woman who had 6 months to live? The doctor told her she should marry a social media consultant. “Why?” the woman asked, “Can social media really cure a terminal disease?”
“No ,” the doctor answered, “but it will be the longest six months of your life.”
It’s a good time to be in social media. We’re really busy. The industry is growing fast. It’s dynamic and fun and we’re helping great organizations grow more efficiently than ever, even in a down economy.
But, the industry is full of challenges. There is a laundry list, but the one on my mind today is the “overpromising” of social media. John McCain would not be president now even if he used social media more effectively, GM would still be in bankruptcy, even if they had a great Facebook page, diseases aren’t cured, wars aren’t won, soulmates don’t meet and recessions aren’t avoided because of social media.
Don’t get me wrong. I’ve been working in social media since the Geocities and Tripod days of 1999. I’ve seen great things happen, but I’ve never seen a social media miracle.
Often times, our phone rings with a new potential client looking to integrate social media into a marketing communications plan. At Webbed, we are very goal oriented and always look to outline clear ways of defining success with new and existing clients. Our goal is to sit down with a client every month and be able to say that without question a program is a success because we are reporting this many sales, leads, media pickups or other clear hard success metric.
But are there times we say no? Absolutely. And there are times you should say no.
1. Social media can’t get people excited about a bad product. No matter how much money you put into social media, eight track players can’t outsell iPods. If the market doesn’t believe in your product, or your clients’ products, don’t think social media will make it better.
2. Social media can’t make people spend money. Yes, you can use social media to get people coming to your paint store. You can target highly qualified consumers with disposable income who want to paint their houses. You can communicate the virtues of the high quality paint in your store. But once a consumer is in the store, especially during a recession, they still may buy the cheap stuff.
3. Social media can’t create a new market. Okay, it created a market for social media consultants-but other than that, forget it. There are only two rules in fishing- the first is “you can’t catch fish where there aren’t fish.” The same applies to marketing. Products that don’t solve a problem or provide real value aren’t going to sell, no matter how many fans there are on their Facebook page.





